Showing posts with label rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rules. Show all posts

Monday, August 16, 2010

Michael Kimmel - The Four Rules of Manhood

Made Possible is a cool new men's site focused on work, play, money, health, and culture - as well as categories under main headings such as for health: mind, body, heart, and fuel.

Nice site with some cool stuff already there so go have a look around.

The first article I saw from the site was this one by veteran men's studies scholar Michael Kimmel. Those are four of the cultural rules for being a man that I was exposed to regularly as I grew up.
The Four Rules of Manhood

Why we can never live up to them—and why we work like crazy to prove to the world otherwise

By Michael Kimmel

"Be a Man!" We've all heard it, whether we said "no" to a round of drinks, or we avoided a girl during an office party so our asshole colleagues didn't give us—or, worse, her—shit about it the next day.

It makes me wince every time I hear it. But there's a deeper consequence that comes with this phrase: we buy into it. And even though it's usually the above jerks who blurt it out, we've heard it all of our lives from people we care about, people we're close to, people we trust. Most guys are reminded of their fathers telling them not to cry and to toughen up. Sometimes it's an older sibling who threatened to kick our ass if we didn't stop being a sissy. For me, it was my baseball coach who thought he was motivating me by repeating those annoying idioms like "no pain, no gain" or "tough it out." As often, too, it was my best friends who used every name they could think of—wimp, faggot, wuss, loser, skirt, queer, pussy, gay—to make sure I buckled under their peer pressure.

Look, I've laughed about it like anybody else. But as innocent and innocuous as we may all think it is to take hits to our manhood, we'd all prefer to avoid being the target of them. So, we all do our best to follow the universal "rules" of manhood:

1. Don't be a sissy:
You can never do anything that even remotely hints of the feminine. In the United States, we don't raise boys to become men, we raise them to not become women.

2. Always win:
Wealth, power, status—these are the markers of masculinity. All right, let's quote a bumper sticker here: "He who has the most toys when he dies wins." Sorry, did I just quote a bumper sticker?

3. Be a sturdy oak: What makes a man is that he is reliable in a crisis. And what makes him reliable is how closely he resembles an inanimate object. A rock, a pillar, a species of tree.

4. Go for it:
Exude an aura of daring and aggression. Live life on the edge, Take risks. Don't give a damn about what others think.

You know these rules because you've had to abide by them at some point in your life. According to James O'Neil, a developmental psychologist at the University of Connecticut, who has dedicated his life to studying masculinity, these are the elements of the code that defines what most men think when they think of what it means to be a man. "One of the more surprising findings," O'Neil once told me, "is how little these rules have changed."

There's another thing O'Neil has observed over the years—and something many of us secretly suspect. It's that these rules are bogus. They're a complete fraud. They're not only impossible to live up to, they're simply ridiculous.

Rather than a prescription for genuine manhood, the ideology contained in these rules is more a blueprint for a robot, a machine, an unfeeling, impervious automaton who is unburdened by such human experiences as love, pain, joy, sorrow, ecstasy, and agony. Is that your idea of a "happy place"?

So, where does that leave us? Well, many of us have grown up with an ideology of masculinity that's impossible to achieve. Then we wonder why we secretly fear that we are not measuring up—and work like crazy to try and prove to the world otherwise.

The good news is that there's another aspect of masculinity, often hidden beneath the relentless overachiever and narcissist in us all. It's better defined by how honorable, ethical, and responsible we can be. It's the part of us that's a caretaker of his family and community, and a caregiver to those he loves. It's the reliable friend, the nurturing father, and the loving, patient husband or partner. It's the man who does well by doing good. Feeling better already?

As someone who has studied the American man—his beliefs, his behaviors—for more than two decades, I've listened to thousands of younger men describe their lives and their aspirations. I've heard enough to know that too many men like you actually do lead lives of quiet desperation under the despotism of "Be a man." With that in mind, we will take the time in this space to debunk the myths of manhood and, better yet, explore how those myths affect your relationships with women, with your colleagues at work, and with your family. They play a role in everything you do, from bringing up kids to dating—even how you perform in bed. Did you get that? You'll be better in bed.

Beyond the sex talk, I'll offer practical advice on what it means to "man up" in every possible life situation. It's what you need to know to build the quiet confidence that keeps you moving forward. And, of course, it's good to keep in mind the next time someone tells you to stop being such a wimp.



Michael Kimmel is among the world's leading researchers on men and masculinity and the author of a dozen books, including Manhood in America and Guyland. He is a professor of sociology at Stony Brook University and lectures about young men in modern society all over the world. Other articles from Michael Kimmel: Dancing Fool

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Diana Kirschner - Relationship Advice: Fight Club Rules

If we want to have a healthy relationship, we need to know how to fight clean and fair. Diana Kirschner's Relationship Advice: Fight Club Rules offers a good set of guidelines on how to do this.

Relationship Advice: Fight Club Rules

Fighting in your relationship: can it be a good thing?

Beware of entrance to a quarrel. ~ Shakespeare

All couples belong to what I call the Fight Club because they all fight. Couples that don't fight are the ones that therapists worry most about. In fact, couples who do not fight have double the divorce rate of those who do. Loving couples do air their differences. But they follow three certain rules to make sure that their disagreement does not turn into World War III with mutual assured destruction.

Fight Club Rule #1: Anger and Criticism Do Not Take Over.
Anger and criticism lead to "flooding," a stress explosion in which the heart beats more rapidly, blood pressure soars and adrenaline surges. The whole body tenses up as fear, confusion and then more anger take over. Reason goes out the window. In experimental studies of conflict, even when couples are asked to calm down, men simply aren't able to while women can. Biologically speaking, men are wired to react more quickly and for a longer time period, probably for vigilance and safety reasons. So that's why it's best to start an interaction that could become a fight in a soft, sweet, or affectionate way with Positive Shaping Talk. While a man can often be triggered by mere criticism, it usually takes contempt or strong denigration to flood a woman.

Loving couples tend to avoid flooding and practice Positive Shaping Talk with each other. They keep anger/upset levels down. And if anger swirls out of control they may use breathing, time out, humor or other Fight Club Rules to defuse the situation.

Fight Club Rule #2: Agree to Disagree
A healthy couple agrees to disagree, discussing differences with respect and self control. They often show each other that they understand the other's point of view. The partners realize that ultimately they both want the same thing: closeness and a sense of shared love. If they feel heard and understood, like their opinion matters, they can often let go of the issue, back down and reenter into an intimate connection. In loving couples, who is right and who is wrong matters much less. In fact, these couples operate out of a fundamental paradox: "I accept you as you are," on the one hand and on the other, "Now will you please change." This paradox is so well known, that it became the title of a long-running Off-Broadway show written by a long-term couple called, I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change.

Fight Club Rule #3: End Conflict in a Win-Win Way
There are several ways you can help end conflict on a positive note. I have often used the "Take Two" technique with couples: either of them was able to call out "Take Two" when a fight erupted and they would start their "scene" all over again, but from a loving place. Couples do this naturally when one of them says something like, "Can we talk about this in a different way?" Or perhaps one partner affectionately teases or soothes the other who is in the midst of flooding and the fight is over then and there. Or they might compromise. The couple may follow a rule, like, Don't let the sun rise on your wrath. Of course, one key to ending a fight is that a partner realizes they are wrong, apologizes and/or makes it up to their Beloved.

In general healthy couples fight, but their fighting is less out of control and ends on a sweet note that carries them back to laughter, closeness and intimacy. Here is how Gina, a therapist herself and former student of mine, describes how she uses Fight Club Rules with her husband:

"He gets so wounded and growls a lot if he thinks I am criticizing him. So I usually bring stuff up when we are lying in bed, feeling close, with our feet touching. It's funny, but doing it this way means we fight a whole lot less."

Remember, practice doing whatever it takes to come out of your anger and create a dialogue. In the midst of a disagreement, take a break, breathe, soothe or calm yourself and try on the other person's point of view. Ask yourself honestly, do you need to back down or make an apology to your partner? When you are fighting, which is more important, being right, or being close? And if your spouse gets flooded with anger, practice using humor, giving them space or soothing them in some way so that they can calm down.

My personal rule fits with this approach -- when we get angry we need to take a step back and see that this is the person we love, the person who we have given ourselves to in trust and affection, and not the enemy.


Friday, April 3, 2009

Is Satire that Hard to Grasp?

Last week I posted TC Luoma's 12 Manliness Guidelines, a fairly tongue-in-cheek list of things men should or should not do to be manly. I didn't take it seriously, mostly because I have been reading TC for a decade now and I know when he is being serious (since it isn't that often, it stands out).

Apparently a lot of T-Nation readers (like about 95%) didn't get it. Here is the beginning of a discussion about the issue in this week's Atomic Dog article.

So let's start by stating the obvious: It's hard as shit to be funny on purpose. I've never heard of this guy, but I agree wholeheartedly with a point he makes: If a reader doesn't understand a poem, he blames himself. If the same reader doesn't get a joke, he blames the writer.

Everything I just said about comedy goes double for satire. And it goes triple for satire on the Internet, a medium that encourages readers to express strong opinions on material they may not have read from beginning to end.

Which brings me to last week's Atomic Dog column, "12 Manliness Guidelines."

You have to go to the eighth page of comments on the discussion thread before a reader drops the S bomb. And that was after TC asked, on the seventh page of the thread, if there was an English major in the house.

TC and I emailed back and forth about the column, and the readers' reaction to it, for several days before we decided it was a good time to give readers some insight into TC's creative process — how much of his material is true (as opposed to "true"), how his perspective and sense of humor have helped define the editorial mission of Testosterone Muscle, and what we hope to accomplish going forward.

TC has talked a lot about his background, his book, and the poorly understood link between poker prowess and the proximity of the cards to the dealer's breasts.

Now it's time to get into some meatier subjects.


Testosterone Muscle:
When I read your Atomic Dog last Friday, it never occurred to me that you were seriously saying real men don't drink wine or beer, or send text messages, or anything like that. I assumed you were satirizing the idea of one guy, or one group of guys, defining manliness for all other guys. But when I read the discussion thread, it looked like at least 95 percent of the posters took it seriously. Did that catch you by surprise?

TM: Sorry to break it to you, but when you look like a Viking, "impish" isn't exactly an option. Okay, truth time: How many of those items in the column actually apply to you, personally? I mean, you're a successful guy, and you never drink wine? Really? To me, it's one of the best reasons to become successful — you can afford more wine, and better wine.

TM: But he's an unattractive, unsuccessful, self-centered jerk who sleeps with Virginia Madsen! If that's not an argument for increased wine consumption, I don't know what is!

You can read the rest of the article at the site.


Saturday, March 28, 2009

TC Luoma - 12 Manliness Guidelines

TC Is a funny guy, and while I'm not sure I'm down with his ideas here (in fact, his Beckham bashing is a little less than mature), he is entertaining to read. Oh yeah, if you are easily offended, please don't read this article.

ATOMIC DOG
12 Manliness Guidelines

Manliness is a funny thing. It's hard to define.

I mean TV and the movies and the commercials — oh, the commercials — have done mucked it up. They done made it a caricature of itself.

They made it so manliness is defined by how much beer you drink and how big your pick-up truck is and whether there's enough mud on it and how many feathers and varieties of fur are on the grill, presumably from 4-wheeling through ecologically sensitive areas and pulverizing some endangered species.

That pseudo-manliness shit, made hard and lumpy by too much popular-culture Metamucil, is hard to filter out. It's hard to keep it from influencing my man meter.

Still, I seem to have an innate sense of what actions are manly and which aren't. I even have a sense of what clothes are manly and what aren't.

But the intellectual part of me says what the hell, how do clothes or fashion or affectations define manliness? They don't, not really. Manliness is defined by actions and quiet confidence and loyalty and nobility and chivalry and a whole bunch of other good words that end in the letter y.

But I've seen things. I've not only seen things, but I've heard some things, Joey; things that make my manliness radar ping — and not just one ping, Vasily, multiple pings. Sounds like an enraged meth freak beating on the hood of a Prius with a fireplace poker.

Maybe there's a special part of our brain, nurtured by pure, high-grade Testosterone, that makes these judgments for us, and arguing about them is like analyzing, or worse, arguing about, why Miss April's sweet ass makes us temporarily forget that our wives, children, parents, or even sweet ol' Nana and Papa ever existed.

Early last year, I wrote about "The Richardson Society," a group of Marines that meet regularly to experience the finer things in life. I wrote how part of their discussion had been about this manliness thing, and they enjoyed debating such things as whether it was manly to wear a sports jersey with some athlete's name and number on the back.

(One of them recently wrote an article about this very topic, but I chose not to read it, lest it influence my list.)

Unlike me, they didn't question that part of the brain that made those decisions. Whether something was manly or not was largely a black or white issue.

Inspired by them, I've chosen to quit intellectualizing the issue and just go with my gut. With that in mind, here's some shit that just doesn't fly on my manliness scale:


1. Wearing a Sports Jersey

The Richardson Society deemed it was okay to wear a sports jersey until you got to high school. I concur. After that, it's got to go to Goodwill.

Idolizing another man merely for his athletic abilities is distasteful in itself, but wearing his name on your back? What's the point? It's not a magic talisman that will grant you the skills of the athlete, nor will it get you any girls, unless you find a nerdy one who's wearing the same jersey.

There is an exception, though. Some clothing items feature the name of a sports franchise or a sports star, but it's used in an ironic sense. If that's the case, feel free to wear it.

Oh wait a minute, I just thought of a second exception. Hot girls can wear anything — including sports jerseys — and get away with it.

12 Manliness Guidelines

2. Wearing a Sports Jersey with Beckham's name on it

Unless you live in Europe (and don't know any better), you shouldn't wear a Beckham jersey if you're older than, say, 6.

Letting a boy older than 6 wear one may affect the young man's sexual development. If you're an adult and you wear one, you can probably get a job guarding a harem.


3. Eating an Ice Cream Cone

Can you imagine Clint Eastwood licking an ice cream cone? No. The thought of it makes you queasy, doesn't it?

Maybe if it had the outline of a vagina made out of sprinkles and a little cherry gummy-bear candy clit, but a plain ice cream cone? No way.


4. Drinking Wine

I'm going to tell you a real-life secret that's more tightly guarded than anything in The Da Vinci Code:

Nobody really likes wine. Really. Oh it's fine to get drunk with, but only people with some whacked out gene that encodes for a faulty receptor protein appreciate wine, along with similar "varietals" like vinegar, cat piss, radiator fluid, or broth made from a fat sweaty girl's panties.

Besides, it's hard to be manly when you pick up that glass with your dainty fingers, swirl it around, take a sip, and get an expression that makes you look like you're getting fellated by a Vietnamese girl with removable teeth.

And I tell you, beer ain't all that much better. It's the polar opposite of wine, but not in a good way. I'll prove it to you: beer commercials. Any self-respecting man would look at any beer commercial, get sick to his stomach at the kind of guy represented therein, and swear off the evil brew forever.

Men drink whiskey, gin, vodka, bourbon, Scotch, or nothing at all, literally. I mean not even water. Okay, okay, water and protein drinks too, but that's it.


5. Texting

Go ahead and text, new-media boy, but unless you're 15 and the star of the delightful comic strip, Zits, you must occasionally converse the old-fashioned way: through speech, otherwise known as the communication or expression of thoughts in spoken words.

Read the rest of the article.