Sunday, April 24, 2011

Men Tend To Leap To Judgement Where Women See More Shades Of Grey

Please note that these are tendencies - this is not how it has to be for men or women. As broad generalizations, these statements might be true for the traditional form of masculinity. And for women, well, I don't know - not my field.

More importantly, they refer to sex differences, which implies a biological distinction. But there is no evidence that this is truly a sex difference and not a gender difference, i.e., a learned behavior. Maybe there is a sex difference, but we will never know that by studying adults - we'd need to look at infants and follow them over many years.

Men Tend To Leap To Judgement Where Women See More Shades Of Grey - New Study

An experiment by researchers at the University of Warwick has found the first real evidence that men tend to make black-or-white judgements when women are more prone to see shades of grey in choices and decisions.

The research paper, entitled Sex Differences in Semantic Categorization, is about to be published in the Archives of Sexual Behavior. Authors Vickie Pasterski, Karolina Zwierzynska, and Zachary Estes are all from the Department of Psychology at the University of Warwick.

The researchers asked 113 people whether each of 50 objects fitted partially, fully, or not at all into certain categories. The 50 objects were ones likely to stimulate debate or disagreement about which category they fitted into. For instance:

Is a tomato a fruit?

Is paint a tool?

The researchers found that men were more likely to make absolute category judgments (e.g., a tomato is either a fruit or not), whereas women made less certain category judgments (e.g., a tomato can "sort of" belong in the fruit category). The women surveyed tended to be much more nuanced in their responses and were 23% more likely to assign an object to the "partial" category.

While it has been a popular belief that such a male/female split exists, as far as the researchers are aware, this is the first time such a sex difference in categorization has been shown experimentally.

University of Warwick psychologist Dr Zachary Estes says:

"Of course, simply because we have found a significant sex difference in how men and women categorize does not mean that one method is intrinsically better than the other. For instance, male doctors may be more likely to quickly and confidently diagnose a set of symptoms as a disease. Although this brings great advantages in treating diseases early, it obviously has massive disadvantages if the diagnosis is actually wrong. In many cases, a more open approach to categorizing or diagnosing would be more effective."

The bibliographic reference:
Pasterski V et al (2011). Sex differences in semantic categorization. Archives of Sexual Behavior; DOI 10.1007/s10508-011-9764-y

No comments: